‘’Immigration Laws are the only laws that are discussed in the terms of how to help people who break them.’’
The following words of Thomas Sowell suggests that when discussing immigration laws, the focus often centres on how to assist or provide support to individuals who have violated these laws. Unlike other laws where the emphasis might be on punishment or deterrent for lawbreakers. Immigration is one of the most complex and divisive issues a country has to deal with. It is vital to critically examine the potential negative consequences it may bring into India which is the risk to National Security and the culture of the land (India), Strain on resources, Social Cohesion and Economic Instability.
One of the most important things for a country is its national security which is challenged by immigration. The inability to conduct proper vetting procedures and monitoring the inflow of every single person provides opportunity for criminal elements, illegal activities, and even terrorism to enter the country. This poses a risk to the safety and well-being of the native population of our country. India is a large country sharing its border with many countries. While legal immigrants are generally law-abiding individuals seeking better opportunities, there is a risk that some individuals may become radicalised within the country. Radicalization can lead to the involvement in extremist activities, including terrorism, which poses a significant threat to national security.In some cases, legal immigrants with access to sensitive information or critical sectors may engage in espionage activities, passing confidential data to foreign entities. This can compromise national security, especially in areas such as defence, technology, and research.
Legal immigration, when not managed carefully, can pose a threat to the cultural diversity of India.One of the most common examples of this is of Language and cultural dominance where once significant numbers of immigrants settle in a specific region. Due to the linguistic barrier the immigrants start to communicate in their native language. As a result, the native population may feel less connected to their cultural roots and traditional practices. It may also give rise to tensions and conflicts between different linguistic and cultural groups.
Furthermore, India is a densely populated country with limited resources and a growing demand for basic necessities like food, water, and shelter. Large-scale immigration requires more resources, subsidies, jobs, infrastructure and healthcare. While some argue that immigration improves the economic standards of a country, they fail to understand the long term impact it holds by reduced wage rates, increased unemployment, inflation, and decrease in job opportunities. In a country like India which is still developing, immigrants pose a strain on the economy and puts the government in a dilemma to choose between its moral obligation towards the immigrants and its national obligation or Rajdharma towards its native citizens.
Lastly, Those who argue that it's a moral obligation for a country to allow those who are knocking on the borders should ask the same question to themselves – Whether they would allow someone unknown into their home or not. While immigration can bring diversity and can break cultural barriers it is essential to recognize the negative impacts it can have on a country like India which is the strain on limited resources, threat to social cohesion, economic instability, and security concerns. These are valid reasons to conclude that immigration is a negative thing for India
Comentários